BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//Prairie Hills Audubon Society - ECPv6.18.4//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://phas-wsd.org
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for Prairie Hills Audubon Society
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:America/Denver
BEGIN:DAYLIGHT
TZOFFSETFROM:-0700
TZOFFSETTO:-0600
TZNAME:MDT
DTSTART:20250309T090000
END:DAYLIGHT
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:-0600
TZOFFSETTO:-0700
TZNAME:MST
DTSTART:20251102T080000
END:STANDARD
BEGIN:DAYLIGHT
TZOFFSETFROM:-0700
TZOFFSETTO:-0600
TZNAME:MDT
DTSTART:20260308T090000
END:DAYLIGHT
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:-0600
TZOFFSETTO:-0700
TZNAME:MST
DTSTART:20261101T080000
END:STANDARD
BEGIN:DAYLIGHT
TZOFFSETFROM:-0700
TZOFFSETTO:-0600
TZNAME:MDT
DTSTART:20270314T090000
END:DAYLIGHT
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:-0600
TZOFFSETTO:-0700
TZNAME:MST
DTSTART:20271107T080000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=America/Denver:20261109T140000
DTEND;TZID=America/Denver:20261120T220000
DTSTAMP:20261117T065956Z
CREATED:20261106T210110Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20261117T065956Z
UID:23399-1794232800-1795212000@phas-wsd.org
SUMMARY:BAAJA permitting bill: Senate final vote expected soon. Call Senators ASAP
DESCRIPTION:Senate permitting bill\, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA\, S. 5653 / H.R. 2347): key Senate vote Monday\, Nov. 16. Call now.\nUpdated Nov. 15\, 2026. Prairie Hills Audubon Society calendar alert. \nCalls to our delegation are not a “waste of time” this time. Sen. Mike Rounds has twice been the only Republican in the Senate to vote against moving this bill forward\, on Nov. 9 and again on Nov. 10. Every other Republican voting\, including Sen. Thune\, voted yes. A South Dakota senator is already willing to buck his party on this bill. He needs to hear that South Dakotans stand with him\, and Sen. Thune needs to hear that his constituents agree with Rounds. \n============ \nUPDATE\, Monday night\, Nov. 16: The Senate voted 70–27 to cut off debate on the BAAJA text\, so it needed 60 and got 70. This was not the final vote. Final Senate passage could come later this week and is expected before Thanksgiving. Senators are still negotiating whether any amendments will get votes. Please keep calling: ask Sen. Thune to allow amendment votes and vote NO on final passage\, and thank Sen. Rounds for past “No votes” and ask him to stay a no on final passage. (We don’t yet know how he voted on 11/16/26) After the Senate\, the bill goes to the House. More details\, including how our senators voted\, will be posted  on PHAS calendar alert…likely posted by Tuesday evening \n====================================== \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nWe give a timeline first\, but below that is the text on the substance of the bill and talking points for contacting congressional delegation.. \nWhat happens Monday 11/16/26\nMonday\, Nov. 16\, about 3:30 p.m. Mountain: The Senate takes a key 60-vote vote to cut off debate on BAAJA. This is not the final vote\, but it is the turning point. If 60 senators vote yes\, debate is limited and final passage could come within a few days\, with little or no chance left to fix the bill. Senators who want amendments\, for example to protect historic and Tribal sites or state water authority\, have their best leverage before this vote. Call Thune and Rounds Monday morning at the latest. Rounds is on our side\, and Thune is in charge of the process. \nHow we got here\n\nMonday\, Nov. 9: The Senate voted 73–25 to end debate on whether to take up the bill. This needed 60 votes.\nTuesday\, Nov. 10: The Senate voted 62–21 to formally take up the bill (H.R. 2347\, a House bill being used as the vehicle for the BAAJA text).\nBoth times\, Sen. Mike Rounds voted NO and Sen. John Thune voted YES.\nWednesday\, Nov. 11: Sen. Thune filed cloture (a motion to cut off debate) on the sponsors’ substitute amendment\, which is the BAAJA text\, and on the bill itself. Each needs 60 votes.\nThursday\, Nov. 12: The Senate turned to judicial nominations and left until Monday\, Nov. 16.\n\nWhat comes after Monday 11/16/26\nThe Senate has to approve two things: first the BAAJA text (offered as a replacement for the text of H.R. 2347)\, then the bill as a whole. Each takes two votes: a 60-vote vote to cut off debate\, then a simple-majority vote to approve it. \n\nMonday\, about 3:30 p.m. Mountain: 60-vote vote to cut off debate on the BAAJA text.\n\nIf it fails (fewer than 60 votes)\, the bill stalls. Steps 2–4 don’t happen unless the leaders make a deal and try again.\nIf it passes\, the Senate may debate the BAAJA text for up to 30 more hours.\n\n\nSimple-majority vote to adopt the BAAJA text\, when those 30 hours run out\, likely Tuesday or Wednesday.\n60-vote vote to cut off debate on the bill as a whole. This usually comes right after step 2\, the same day. If it passes\, up to 30 more hours of debate are allowed.\nFinal passage\, by simple majority\, likely Wednesday or Thursday.\n\nAmendments are usually voted on before the BAAJA text is adopted (step 2). That makes Monday through about Wednesday the window. Senators often agree to give up some or all of the debate time. If they do\, steps 2–4 could come sooner\, even late Monday night. The schedule can change at any time\, so calls are useful right up to final passage. Amendments can be added during the debate times. \nUp to 30 hours of debate are allowed after each 60-vote vote\, but senators often agree to skip that time\, so final passage could come mid-week. Senate schedules change often\, so check back here. \nAmendments. Senators can file amendments\, but filing doesn’t guarantee a vote. Which amendments get votes is usually decided in a deal between the Majority Leader (Thune) and the Democratic Leader (Schumer)\, often around a cloture vote like Monday’s. Schumer has said he will pursue amendments. Amendments being pushed include ones to remove the historic preservation changes and to limit “project certainty\,” which makes permits issued now hard for a future administration to revoke. \nMore than 90 legal scholars urge senators to strip 12 provisions. In a letter drafted by the Center for Progressive Reform\, law professors from around the country say they support building clean energy and transmission quickly\, but warn that BAAJA would do “permanent\, sweeping damage on the nation’s core environmental laws.” They ask the Senate to use the amendment process to remove 12 provisions\, including “forever permits\,” taxpayer payouts to developers\, courts unable to fix violations\, closed courthouse doors\, weakened state and Tribal water authority\, a weakened Endangered Species Act\, and sidelining Tribal Nations and sacred places.\nSummary: https://progressivereform.org/cpr-blog/legal-scholars-to-senate-here-are-12-provisions-of-permitting-bill-that-should-not-become-law/\nLetter: https://progressivereform.org/publications/legal-scholars-ltr-us-senate-on-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act/ \nAfter the Senate\, the bill goes back to the House. \n======================================= \nWhat to do\nCall as an individual constituent. Offices open at 7 a.m. Mountain and take voicemail after hours. \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nWho\nAsk\nPhone\n\n\n\n\nSen. John Thune\nDon’t rush this through. Allow full debate and real votes on amendments. Vote NO on cutting off debate Monday and NO on final passage.\nDC (202) 224-2321 · Rapid City (605) 348-7551\n\n\nSen. Mike Rounds\nThank him for voting no twice. Ask him to stay a no Monday and on final passage\, and to support good amendment votes.\nDC (202) 224-5842 · Rapid City (605) 343-5035\n\n\nRep. Dusty Johnson\nOppose the bill when it reaches the House. (He voted for the House version\, the SPEED Act.)\nDC (202) 225-2801\n\n\n\nCapitol switchboard: (202) 224-3121. \nWhy ask Thune about the process?\nAs Majority Leader\, Thune controls the process more than anyone else: \n\nHe decides what reaches the floor and when. He scheduled Monday’s vote.\nHe decides how fast to push. He filed cloture to cut off debate. He could also let debate run longer.\nHe negotiates the amendment list with Schumer. That deal decides which amendments\, if any\, get votes. The bill’s sponsors (Capito\, Lee\, Whitehouse\, Heinrich) also have a big say\, and they tend to resist amendments that could break their deal.\n\nPrefer to write? Ready-made letters\nThese tools send a pre-written letter for you. Tip: form letters are usually counted\, not read. Your letter carries more weight if you add a sentence or two of your own at the top\, saying where you live and why it matters to you. Better still\, copy the text into the senator’s own contact form at thune.senate.gov or rounds.senate.gov\, or Rep. Johnson’s at dustyjohnson.house.gov. Pick “Environment” or “Energy” as the topic. \n\nEarthjustice Action (Senate and House): earthjusticeaction.org\nAnimal Commons\, Endangered Species Coalition and others: actionnetwork.org\n“Stop the Lame-Duck Congress” letter: actionnetwork.org · endangered species version: actionnetwork.org\nDefenders of Wildlife: act.defenders.org · WildEarth Guardians: wildearthguardians.org · Western Watersheds Project: westernwatersheds.org\nSample endangered species letter to copy into a senator’s form (IFAW): ifaw.org\nCall script with choices of concerns (5 Calls): 5calls.org\n\nSome of these were written before the Nov. 9 vote. If a letter mentions an earlier date\, change it to “vote no on cutting off debate Monday\, Nov. 16\, and no on final passage.” \nWhat to say: four short points\nThe bill runs nearly 500 pages\, so no one can cover it in a phone call. Pick one or two of these and say them in your own words. \n1. It’s not just about energy. The bill rewrites the basic environmental laws themselves. That changes the rules for every timber sale\, mine\, road and grazing decision on the Black Hills National Forest\, not just power plants and pipelines. \n2. It shuts South Dakotans out. The Forest Service already gives the public as little as 15 days to comment on a project. This bill narrows public review even further: fewer projects would get an environmental review at all\, the reviews that remain would consider fewer choices\, and fewer projects would offer the public a chance to comment (see “NEPA” below). It gives citizens only 150 days to go to court\, down from up to six years. And a court could not stop a project even after finding the law was broken. \n3. It weakens protection for endangered species and sacred sites. It shortens and weakens the reviews that protect species like the whooping crane\, pallid sturgeon and black-footed ferret. It would also let a state take over the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s role in reviewing federal projects’ harm to endangered species\, even a state with no endangered species law of its own. In South Dakota\, that review could fall to Game\, Fish and Parks. It also weakens the main law Tribes rely on to protect sacred places off their reservations\, including the Black Hills. The Great Plains Tribal Chairman’s Association and national tribal organizations oppose the bill even after the latest changes. \n4. It locks in this administration’s decisions. Under “project certainty\,” most federal permits in effect from this fall on would be very hard for a future administration to revoke or change. That would freeze in place projects approved under more than 580 environmental rollbacks created by the second Trump administration.. \nBonus point: fix the real cause of delay. Studies\, including a 2026 Government Accountability Office report on Forest Service timber sales\, point to understaffed agencies\, not environmental laws. Staff the agencies instead of cutting the public out. \nSample messages\nThune: \n“I’m a constituent from [town]. This 500-page bill was rewritten two days before the first vote. Please don’t rush it through in a lame-duck session. As Majority Leader\, please negotiate enough time for full debate and a fair chance for senators to offer amendments and get votes on them. And vote NO on cutting off debate Monday and NO on final passage of S. 5653. It isn’t just about energy. It rewrites the laws that give South Dakotans a voice on Black Hills timber sales\, mines and roads and other projects in SD\, and it limits citizens access to courts. Please allow a vote on an amendment to remove the bill’s historic preservation changes\, and protect South Dakota Tribes’ right to real consultation.It also weakens endangered species protection and lets the state take over the Fish and Wildlife Service’s role. Fix permitting delays by staffing the agencies\, not by cutting out the public.” \nRounds: \n“I’m a constituent from [town]. Thank you for voting against advancing the permitting bill\, S. 5653. Please stay a no on Monday’s vote and on final passage\, and please support votes on amendments. It would cut South Dakotans out of decisions about our public lands and water.” \nWant to understand more? The two big pieces\, in plain language\nNEPA: “look before you leap”\nWhat it does now. The National Environmental Policy Act (1970) requires federal agencies to study a project’s effects before approving it. They must consider alternatives and let the public comment. That’s how ranchers\, hunters\, Tribes and other neighbors learn about a Black Hills timber sale or mine in time to fix problems. If an agency skips steps\, citizens can go to court. \nWhat the bill changes (according to analyses by the Bipartisan Policy Center\, Earthjustice and others): \n\nFewer projects reviewed. It narrows which federal actions need review and exempts more projects completely.\nNarrower choices. Agencies would have to drop alternatives that don’t meet the developer’s goals\, and could ignore new information that appears after a review begins.\nLess time to challenge. Lawsuits must be filed within 150 days instead of up to six years\, and only by people who commented and can show direct harm.\nWeaker remedies. If a court finds a review was illegal\, it can only send it back to the agency. The project goes ahead in the meantime.\nNot limited to energy. These changes apply to almost any project that needs a federal permit. A separate provision sets the same 150-day limit for lawsuits under any federal law (such as the Endangered Species Act or the National Forest Management Act) that challenge energy\, mining and forest management projects. The two limits run at the same time; they do not add up to 300 days.\n\nHow much time does the public get to comment on NEPA reviews?\nIt is already very short\, before this bill passes. A Forest Service rule finalized in October 2026 cut the public comment period to 15 days for an environmental assessment (EA)\, down from 30\, and 30 days for an environmental impact statement (EIS)\, down from 45. Objections\, the last chance to raise problems before a decision\, are due within 10 days after a draft EA decision or 20 days after a draft EIS decision\, with page limits of 15 and 30 pages. \nMeanwhile\, the documents are harder to read quickly. Since 2023\, federal law has capped EAs at 75 pages and EISs at 150 pages (300 for complex projects)\, but appendices don’t count. So more of the key information is moved into long appendices. Fifteen days is not enough for volunteers to learn that a document exists\, read it and its appendices\, and write useful comments. It is also not enough time for a county commission or city council to meet and vote on a response. \nWhat BAAJA adds: \n\nThe only public comment period the bill guarantees comes at the very start of an EIS\, when the agency announces it will prepare one (45 to 60 days). That is before there is any analysis of impacts or alternatives to comment on. The bill does not require a draft EIS to be released for public comment.\nThe bill requires no comment period at all for EAs\, the review used for most Black Hills timber sales.\nTo go to court later\, a citizen must have filed a comment “sufficiently detailed” to flag the exact issue they sue over. Form letters don’t count. So the public would have to spot every problem early\, often before the analysis even exists.\n\nThe result: shorter documents\, shorter deadlines\, fewer chances to comment\, and a lawsuit that depends on having commented in exactly the right way. Ordinary people and local governments can’t keep up with that pace. \nBlack Hills example: If the Forest Service approves a timber sale with a flawed review\, local people today have years to find a lawyer and challenge it. Under this bill they would have 150 days. Even if they won\, the logging could continue while the agency rewrote its paperwork. \nThe Endangered Species Act: the science and the check\nWhat it does now. Before a federal agency approves a project that could harm a listed species\, it must consult with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The Service reviews the best available science and decides whether the project would jeopardize the species. Its decision is called a biological opinion. \nWhat the bill changes (according to the Congressional Research Service and the 215 groups that signed the Oct. 6 letter opposing these provisions): \n\nA new definition of “best available science.” It raises the bar for which science counts. Critics say incomplete data\, which is common for rare and hard-to-study species\, could become a reason not to protect them. This applies to listing decisions as well as project reviews.\nLess time. Formal consultation is cut from 90 to 60 days.\nStates can take over. A state could take over the Fish and Wildlife Service’s role for projects inside its borders\, even if it has no endangered species law of its own.\nHarder to challenge. Challenges to biological opinions must be filed within 150 days and only in the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals.\nApplies to all projects\, not just energy. The only exemption is for certain highway work.\n\n“Project certainty”: locking in today’s decisions\nSupporters wrote “project certainty” (Title IV\, Sections 1401–1403) to stop a president from cancelling approved wind and solar projects. But it is written to protect almost every federal permit\, and critics consider it the most dangerous part of the bill. The sponsors revised it on Nov. 7. The description below reflects those revisions as reported by the Institute for Progress (which supports the bill)\, Earthjustice and the Clean Air Task Force (which do not)\, and the Center for Western Priorities. \nWhat it does (Section 1401). Once a project has a federal permit\, agencies may not revoke\, suspend or materially change it\, or take “any new action” that interferes with its operation at “normal capacity\,” except in listed cases: \n\naction taken in response to a court order;\nthe permit holder violated the permit or the law;\nthe permit was obtained by fraud or material misrepresentation;\naction needed to prevent immediate harm to life\, property\, national security\, human health or the environment. The words “human health” and “the environment” were added Nov. 7\, but Earthjustice warns that the word “immediate” sets the bar so high it would not cover\, for example\, a project that raises cancer risks. Any response must be “narrowly tailored.”\naction “taken pursuant to any applicable law or regulation\,” a new catch-all exception;\nthe permit holder asks for the change.\n\nThe revisions also added a “savings clause” saying the section does not limit agencies’ authority under other laws. \nDo the Nov. 7 changes fix it? The two sides disagree. \n\nSupporters (Institute for Progress) say the new catch-all exception and savings clause mean agencies can still issue new rules and make lawful permit changes\, and courts can still overturn illegal permits.\nCritics (Earthjustice\, Clean Air Task Force) say the catch-all and savings clause are vague\, and that courts are unlikely to read them so broadly that they cancel out the rest of Section 1401. The meaning would be fought out in court for years. Earthjustice says the “forever permits” problem remains: most permits still could not be revoked or changed except in very limited circumstances. And changes could come only after a court ruling\, which in turn depends on someone filing a lawsuit within the bill’s shortened deadlines.\n\nPenalties for agencies. If an agency interferes with a permit without proving an exception\, the company can sue for reinstatement\, attorney fees and delay costs. If the agency acted in bad faith\, it can also seek damages of 25% to 50% of the project’s development and construction costs\, paid from the federal Judgment Fund. That money comes from taxpayers. The Nov. 7 revisions added the bad-faith requirement and require a court judgment or a court-approved settlement before payment. \nIt is not limited to energy. It applies to most federal permits and authorizations\, so it could cover timber sales\, mining plans\, grazing and special-use permits\, pipelines and data centers. \nWhich permits does it cover? This is unclear\, and it matters. \n\nPermits in effect from this fall on: clearly covered. The bill as introduced covered permits “effective on or after September 16\, 2026\,” two weeks before the bill was introduced. The Center for Western Priorities reports that the amended bill uses Nov. 6\, 2026. Either way\, the cutoff falls before the bill would become law\, so approvals made this fall would be locked in.\nOlder permits: possibly covered. “In effect on or after” a date could\, read literally\, include permits issued years earlier that are still in effect. The Congressional Research Service flagged this ambiguity in the bill as introduced. Courts would decide.\nPermits in court: not clearly addressed. Agencies may act “in response to” a court order. But other parts of the bill limit what courts can order: for NEPA and some Clean Water Act violations\, courts generally could not throw out a permit\, only send it back for more review while it stays in effect. None of the analyses we found settle how pending cases would be treated.\n\nWhy this connects to the 580-plus rollbacks. NRDC’s White House Watch (https://www.nrdc.org/resources/white-house-watch-tracking-attacks-our-environment-health) reports that since January 2025 this administration has taken or proposed at least 580 actions that threaten the environment\, climate and human health. They include rescinding the federal NEPA regulations and the Forest Service’s own NEPA rules\, weakening Endangered Species Act rules\, shortening Forest Service comment periods\, and proposing to repeal the 2001 Roadless Rule. Those are rules\, and a future administration can rewrite rules. But the permits issued while the weakened rules are in place are another matter. Under project certainty\, a timber sale\, mine or pipeline approved under today’s rules would stay approved even after better rules are restored. The rollbacks would be temporary on paper\, but projects approved under the rollbacks would be permanent on the ground. \nBlack Hills example: A timber sale on the Black Hills National Forest approved this fall or later under the new 15-day comment rule would be very hard for a future Forest Service to cancel or scale back. That would hold even if new data showed the forest was being cut faster than it grows\, because “new science” is not itself an exception. \n“Disparate treatment” lawsuits (Section 1402). Developers of energy projects\, including oil\, gas\, coal\, mining\, nuclear\, wind and solar\, could sue if an agency approves their type of project less often than it did over the previous ten years\, by denying permits in bad faith or letting them run more than 60 days past a deadline as part of an intentional pattern. Damages could reach 50% to 100% of the project’s expected construction cost\, paid by taxpayers. Critics note the ten-year baseline includes both Trump administrations. \nA new decision deadline (Section 1403). Agencies would have one year to decide on any project that doesn’t need an EA or EIS\, and applicants could sue to enforce it. \nSources: Congressional Research Service report R49511 (on the bill as introduced); Institute for Progress\, Earthjustice and Clean Air Task Force analyses of the Nov. 7 manager’s amendment; Center for Western Priorities; NRDC White House Watch. \nTribal Nations\, treaties and sacred places\nWhy this matters so much in South Dakota. American Indians are about 9% of South Dakota’s population in Census Bureau figures\, more if you count people of more than one race. The real number is likely higher still: the Census Bureau’s own follow-up survey found that the 2020 census missed about 5.6% of American Indians living on reservations\, the worst undercount of any group\, and reservations have been undercounted in every census since at least 1990. South Dakota has nine reservations\, which cover about 12% of the state’s land. Many places sacred to the Lakota\, Dakota and Nakota lie off today’s reservations: the Black Hills (He Sapa)\, Bear Butte and many others. The Black Hills were promised to the Sioux Nation/Oceti Sakowin in the 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty. In 1980 the U.S. Supreme Court held that they were taken illegally. \nThe law Tribes rely on. Tribes don’t own most of these places\, so their main legal tool is Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. It requires federal agencies to consult with Tribes before approving a project that could harm sites of religious and cultural importance\, on or off reservations. Tribes also use NEPA\, the Clean Water Act and the courts. For example\, the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe’s challenge to the Dakota Access pipeline’s environmental review was a NEPA case. \nWhat the Nov. 7 revisions fixed. To be fair\, the sponsors’ substitute amendment made some changes Tribes asked for. It dropped a proposed federal redefinition of Tribal sacred places. It dropped a provision letting the federal government take over Tribal Historic Preservation Offices. It required consultation on the report identifying sites a project would affect. And it kept Tribal site databases confidential. \nWhat Tribes say is still wrong. The National Congress of American Indians\, the Native American Rights Fund\, the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers and other tribal organizations\, including the Great Plains Tribal Chairman’s Association\, say the revised bill still: \n\nlets federal officials end historic preservation review on their own\, over Tribal objections\, if they decide harm won’t disqualify a site or that “other considerations” outweigh preservation;\ndoes not require true government-to-government consultation\, meaning officials sitting down with Tribal leaders to resolve harm to sacred sites;\nnarrows which projects trigger historic preservation review at all;\nleaves the Historic Preservation Fund\, which supports Tribal preservation offices\, dependent on annual appropriations;\nkeeps the other changes that affect Tribes: tighter limits on Clean Water Act certification (which Tribes with approved water programs use)\, waivers of consultation for Army Corps nationwide permits\, state takeover of endangered species reviews\, the 150-day lawsuit deadline\, and “project certainty” that locks permits in.\n\nTribal organizations asked Congress to hold the bill until the next Congress can consult with Tribal Nations properly. The bill was negotiated for more than a year behind closed doors\, without government-to-government consultation. That is exactly the process failure the bill would write into law. \nOther changes worth knowing\n\nClean Water Act: It limits South Dakota’s and Tribes’ authority to put water-quality conditions on federal permits for pipelines and other projects.\nMining: Coalition analyses say it gives mining companies\, foreign-owned ones included\, a permanent right to use public land for waste dumps\, roads and pipelines. The Black Hills already have Gilt Edge\, a Superfund site\, and new gold\, lithium\, uranium and rare earth proposals.\n\nWhy permits are slow\nThe evidence points to agency capacity more than the laws: \n\nThe Government Accountability Office’s June 2026 report on Forest Service timber sales found that officials and stakeholders on all sides say the agency needs more staff with the right expertise.\nA University of Utah study of 41\,000 Forest Service NEPA decisions found that delays came mostly from inadequate budgets\, staff turnover\, slow information from applicants and other laws\, not from NEPA itself.\n\nFriends and family in other states\nMonday’s vote needs 60 senators\, so a handful of Democrats decide it. Ask people in other states to check how their senators voted on the BAAJA scorecard (below). They can thank senators who voted no and ask those who voted yes to vote no on cutting off debate Monday and no on final passage. \nWrite a letter to the editor\nThe New York Times (Nov. 12) and the Washington Post (Nov. 9) have both run editorials urging the Senate to pass this bill\, and they treat it as just an energy and climate bill. Neither explains what it does to national forests\, endangered species\, sacred sites or the public’s right to go to court. A short letter from someone who lives with those effects can fill that gap\, and local papers welcome letters too. \n\nWrite it in your own words. The Post does not accept letters written or edited with AI tools.\nNew York Times: 150 to 200 words\, to letters@nytimes.com. Letters must answer a piece from the past week\, so send by Thursday\, Nov. 19 to answer the Nov. 12 editorial\, “Democrats\, Take the Deal.”\nWashington Post: under 300 words\, to letters@washpost.com\, answering the Nov. 9 editorial\, “A major step toward historic permitting reform.” Send as soon as you can.\nPaste the letter into the body of the email (no attachments)\, and include your name\, town and phone number.\nUse one local example (a timber sale\, a mine\, a sacred site\, a species) and one or two of the points above.\n\nPHAS has a short guide with the papers’ rules\, points to make and checked facts: “How to Write a Letter to the Editor on the Senate Permitting Bill (BAAJA)”: https://phas-wsd.org/wp-content/uploads/BAAJA_Letters_to_Editor_Guide_v9.pdf \nMore information\nPHAS documents\n\nPHAS alert focused on national forests: https://phas-wsd.org/wp-content/uploads/PHAS_BAAJA_Forest_Alert_v5-2.pdf\nPHAS guide to writing letters to the editor: https://phas-wsd.org/wp-content/uploads/BAAJA_Letters_to_Editor_Guide_v9.pdf\nPHAS sheet\, “What Does BAAJA Apply To?” (which kinds of projects each part of the bill covers\, and its 150-day lawsuit deadlines): https://phas-wsd.org/wp-content/uploads/BAAJA_Scope_What_It_Applies_To_v6-1.pdf\n\nBill text and trackers\n\nBill text and status: Congress.gov\, S. 5653\nBAAJA scorecard (how members of Congress voted and stand): parksgc.github.io/baaja-scorecard · Substack: The BAAJA Scorecard\nNeutral explainer: Bipartisan Policy Center\nCongressional Research Service: R49510 (NEPA) · R49504 (ESA) · R49511 (project certainty)\n\nAnalyses of the bill\n\nEarthjustice guide to the bill’s impacts: earthjustice.org\nEarthjustice on the Nov. 7 manager’s amendment: earthjustice.org · Institute for Progress (supports the bill): ifp.org (PDF)\nClean Air Task Force on the project certainty revisions: catf.us\nNRDC assessment: nrdc.org · NRDC\, Hard Questions About the Permitting Bill\nEarthjustice: What Will BAAJA Do? Whatever the Trump Administration Wants · How the Senate’s Permitting Bill Could Lock in Deep-Sea Mining\nColumbia Law School: Senate Bipartisan Permit Reform Bill Would Upend Many Environmental Laws\nYale Journal on Regulation: The Muddy Waters of BAAJA\nUnion of Concerned Scientists: The Senate Permitting Deal Could Lock in Fossil Fuel Dominance for Generations\nJeremy Symons (Substack): This is not the permit reform deal that was advertised (much of it on project certainty)\nDavid Bookbinder\, legal analysis\nHolland & Knight (law firm summary): hklaw.com\nFishery Friendly Climate Action Campaign: The Permitting Bill Fishermen Can’t Afford to Ignore\n\nFact sheets and toolkits\n\nDefenders of Wildlife advocacy toolkit (shared by the Endangered Species Coalition): defenders.org (PDF)\nFact sheets: Oceana · Center for Biological Diversity · Defenders of Wildlife · Climate Justice Alliance\, Myths vs. Facts\nOcean Climate Action toolkit: Google Doc\n\nLetters and statements opposing the bill\n\n215-group letter on the Endangered Species Act provisions (Oct. 6): Center for Biological Diversity (PDF)\nTribal organizations’ statement (Nov. 8; signers include the Great Plains Tribal Chairman’s Association): ncai.org · NCAI on the manager’s amendment: ncai.org · 106 Strong coalition: 106strong.com\nState attorneys general (CA\, MA\, WA\, AZ\, DE\, IL\, ME\, OR\, VT): letter (PDF)\nEnvironmental Council of the States: letter (PDF)\nSenators Duckworth\, Wyden\, Merkley and Markey: joint letter\nNGO letter on the bill’s ocean provisions: Oceana (PDF)\nNational Parks Conservation Association position: npca.org\nCenter for Western Priorities and Earthworks (with map of public lands at risk): westernpriorities.org\nPress releases: Defenders of Wildlife · Center for Biological Diversity · The Wilderness Society · Southern Environmental Law Center · WE ACT · Oil Change International\nRefaluwasch Journal of Knowledge and Culture: statement\nWestern Environmental Law Center: westernlaw.org\n\nNews coverage\n\nKOTA-TV (Rapid City)\, Nov. 12: Senate vote advances BAAJA debate as opponents urge South Dakotans to speak out\nHeatmap: John Podesta Says Permitting Deal Hands Trump ‘a Loaded Howitzer’\nPolitico Pro (subscription): Here’s what’s inside the Senate’s new bipartisan permitting proposal\nCommon Dreams: commondreams.org\n\nBackground used in this alert\n\nNRDC White House Watch (tracker of 580 administration actions): nrdc.org/trump-watch\nForest Service rule shortening comment and objection periods (Federal Register\, Oct. 13\, 2026): govinfo.gov\nGAO\, Forest Service timber sale management (June 2026): GAO-26-107993 (PDF)\nCensus Bureau on the 2020 undercount\, including American Indians on reservations: census.gov\nSouth Dakota’s nine tribes and reservations (SD News Watch): sdnewswatch.org\n\nPermission is granted to reproduce this alert for non-commercial advocacy purposes. Prairie Hills Audubon Society\, phas-wsd.org \n 
URL:https://phas-wsd.org/event/expected-monday-nov-9-senate-vote-on-the-permitting-bill-that-would-weaken-nepa-esa-the-clean-water-act/
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR